Laser Design Inc

952-252-3479

Menu
  • Home
  • Products
      • 3D Scanners
          • Portable 3D Scanners
            • Portable 3D Scanners

              Portable Scanners are the ideal option to quickly scan complex shapes and geometric data from objects large or small when you want to go anywhere and inspect anything.

              Portable Scanners >

            • Close
          • Desktop 3D Scanner
            • Desktop Scanner

              Desktop Scanners are the ideal option to quickly scan complex shapes and geometric data from small objects.

              Desktop Scanner >

            • Close
          • Long-Range Scanner
            • Long-Range Scanner

              3D portable scanner that capture precise dimensions of large objects such as wind turbines, ship propellers, airplanes and buildings. Producing 3D scans of the highest quality.

              Long-Range Scanner >

            • Close
          • CT (X-ray) Scanners
            • CT (X-ray) Scanners

              Capture all geometry, both external and internal, of complex and free-form parts.

              CT Scanning Systems make non-destructive evaluation possible.

              CT Systems >

            • Close
          • Metrology Grade Scanners
            • Metrology Grade Scanners

              Need to capture ultra-precise surface data for reverse engineering and inspection?

              3D laser scanning with our high precision scanners are a great solution.

              Metrology Grade Scanners >

            • Close
          • Body Scanners
            • Body Scanners

              3D human body scanners obtain 3D images and models in seconds, making this an ideal solution for full body digitizing and human body modeling.

              3D Body Scanners >

            • Close
        • Close
      • Software & Accessories
          • 3D Anti-Glare Spray
            • 3D Anti-Glare Spray

              To achieve optimal accuracy and results with 3D laser scanning it is often necessary to apply an anti-reflection coating. Helling 3D Scan Spray is especially designed for this purpose.

              3D Scan Spray>

            • Close
          • Artec Studio
            • Artec Studio

              Industry acclaimed software for professional 3D scanning and data processing.

              Artec Studio>

            • Close
          • InnovMetric-Polyworks Software
            • InnovMetric-Polyworks Software

              PolyWorks is a powerful industrial 3D metrology software solution.

              Polyworks Software>

            • Close
          • Geomagic Software
            • Geomagic Software

              Geomagic software offers products for 3D digital realities.

              Geomagic Software>

            • Close
          • SpaceClaim Software
            • SpaceClaim Software

              SpaceClaim empowers engineers to be more creative and deliver products to market faster.

              SpaceClaim Software >

            • Close
          • Volume Graphics Software
            • Volume Graphics Software

              Volume Graphics offers a range of products for the visualization and analysis of CT data and has become a virtual standard for industrial voxel data analysis.

              VG Software >

            • Close
          • ExactFlat Software
            • ExactFlat Software

              ExactFlat enables manufacturers to design, flatten, conduct pattern engineering, nest, cost and create manufacturing and business documentation all on one platform.

              ExactFlat>

            • Close
        • Close
    • Close
  • Services
      • 3D Scanning
          • Parts & Objects
            • 3D Scanning - Parts & Objects

              3D scanning converts physical objects into precise digital models, enabling you to quickly and accurately capture your object’s shape and geometries.

              3D Scanning>

            • Close
          • Buildings & Structures (BIM)
            • 3D Scanning - Buildings & Structures

              Terrestrial 3D scanning is a ground-based technique for collecting high-density spatial imaging with millions of coordinates quickly and accurately.

              Buildings & Structures (BIM)>

            • Close
          • Aircraft, Vehicles & Large Objects
            • Aircraft, Vehicles & Other Large Objects

              Terrestrial & Mobile 3D scanning are techniques for collecting high-density spatial imaging with millions of coordinates quickly and accurately for your aircraft, vehicles and vessels.

              Large Object 3D Scanning>

            • Close
          • ITAR – Weapons
            • ITAR - Weapons

              Laser Design is committed to investing in secure resources that ensure that all of our ITAR data is stored in a manner that meets or exceeds the ITAR requirements. With Laser Design you know your ITAR project is not only compliant but being fulfilled by a company that is registered.

              ITAR - Weapons>

            • Close
          • Industrial CT Scanning
            • Industrial CT Scanning

              Metrology grade Computed Tomography (CT) inspection allows a complete 3D capture of complex internal geometry of parts without needing visual access – the process is nondestructive.

              CT Scanning>

            • Close
          • Reverse Engineering
            • Reverse Engineering

              Reverse engineering using 3D scan data is the most efficient way to generate a CAD model from a physical object that has any kind of complex or freeform shape.

              Reverse Engineering>

            • Close
          • Inspection & Metrology
            • Inspection & Metrology

              Helping to solve your most demanding dimensional inspection issues, digitizing, calibration, certification and all other facets of manufacturing that have to do with 3D metrology.

              Inspection & Metrology>

            • Close
        • Close
      • Point Cloud Modeling
        • Point Cloud Modeling

          If you have a scanner but would like help taking your point clouds to CAD format then let the 3D experts help! Everything from small plastic parts, blades to entire ships and buildings.

          Point Cloud Modeling>

        • Close
      • Scanner Rentals
        • Scanner Rentals

          Laser Design’s knowledgeable rental staff has actual project experience with the 3D equipment we provide.

          Scanner Rentals>

        • Close
      • 3D Photorealistic Rendering
        • 3D Photorealistic Rendering

          Moving from 2D to 3D improves how your ideas and concepts are shown and communicated. When you’re able to show your designs in 3D verses a static 2D drawing the experience is more realistic.

          3D Photorealistic Rendering>

        • Close
    • Close
  • Solutions
      • Industries
          • Aerospace
          • Anthropology
          • Architecture, Engineering, Construction
          • Automotive
          • Bridge
          • Consumer Electronics
          • Defense
          • Education
          • Entertainment
          • Forensics
          • Foundry
          • Heavy Machinery
          • Heritage
          • Hydro Power
          • Law Enforcement
          • Legal
          • Machine Shop
          • Marine
          • Medical
          • Mining
          • Oil & Gas
          • Online Retail
          • Orthotics and Prosthetics
          • Petrochemical
          • Plastics
          • Power Generation
          • Tunnels
          • Wind Power
        • Close
      • Applications
          • 2D to 3D CAD Conversion
          • Accident Reconstruction
          • Alignment
          • As-Built Documentation
          • Asset and Facility Management
          • Body Scanning Application
          • CAD-Based Inspection
          • Class A Surfacing
          • CGI and Visual Effects
          • Contract Inspection
          • Computer Aided Verification
          • Crime Scene Analysis
          • Dimensional Analysis
          • Electronic Site Survey
          • Emergency Response Scanning
          • FEA – Finite Element Analysis
          • First Article Inspection
          • Form Analysis
          • Gear Inspection
          • Incoming Inspection
          • In-Process Inspection
          • Large Part Inspection
          • Litigation Support
          • Machine Calibration
          • Non-Contact Inspection
          • Photorealistic Modeling
          • Product Design
          • Reverse Engineering
          • Robot Calibration
          • Scene Documentation
          • Tool Building and Setup
          • Virtual Simulation
        • Close
    • Close
  • About Us
    • About Laser Design
    • Why Choose Laser Design?
    • Customer Testimonials
    • 3D Technologies Used
    • Careers
    • Partner Programs
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Contact Us
    • Locations
    • Close
  • Locations
    • United States Locations
    • Close
  • Learning Portal
    • Sample Files
    • Blog
    • Case Studies
    • News
    • Videos
    • What is 3D Scanning?
    • 3D Technology Glossary
    • ROI of 3D Scanning
    • Close
  • Contact Us

As-Built vs. Design Intent: A Reverse Engineering Dilemma

November 20, 2014 by Andrew Larson

img19Laser Design Inspection Services has been a leading provider of dimensional inspection, 3D laser scanning, terrestrial scanning, and CT scanning services forover 25 years. The company’s metrologists and engineers are experienced in the automotive, defense, electronics, and many other manufacturing industries. One issue that has been common in reverse engineering scanning projects for all industries over the years is making sure that customers know exactly what type of CAD file deliverable they want from Laser Design based on what they will be doing with the data and their budget.

Sometimes customers have a mistaken perception that 3D laser scanning means placing their part in a magic scanning box, pressing a button, and presto, a perfect 360-degree parametric model emerges, ready to be used in any CAD, CAM, CAE, or rapid prototyping application. Not so says Larry Carlberg, Laser Design and Laser Design Sales Manager. “The results of laser scanning run along a continuum of relatively simple to extremely complex model formats. Cost, time, and level of communication required increase along with the complexity of the results desired. At Laser Design we always ask customers what they will be doing with their CAD files, so we can provide them with the correct level of complexity and file format.”

img20One of the first questions in reverse engineering applications is always, “do you want the data to reflect the as-built part that is being scanned, or to create a perfect CAD model reflecting the original design intent?” When this question is clearly understood and addressed, then Laser Design can provide optimal results for every customer. Unfortunately, reverse engineering is a process and real parts as manufactured never exactly match the unambiguous design; there are always some variations which can be shown in an inspection report.

Obvious flaws such as damaged, broken, or worn areas on a part need fixing, but other manufacturing defects create grey areas. Does the customer want manufacturing defects such as core shift, sink, shrink, warpage, flash parting line, dam, sprue, gate or injector pin artifacts, corrected? Is mirroring one side of an obviously symmetrical design intent does each side need to be unique to better replicate the current manufactured part? We often scan a complete symmetrical part and try to design with symmetry by averaging in the middle of both sides. However, the final part may end up with significant deviations from the actual scanned part to achieve this symmetry in the CAD model. Are there design modifications that need to be included?

img21

Customers often know what they want to accomplish, but not what type of model they actually need to do so. Some engineers are still used to working with 2D prints or 2D AutoCAD drawings. However, these drawings often contain conflicting information: dimensions that don’t add up, lines that are misplaced or slightly off, undefined blend areas, etc. When a 3D CAD file is created from an actual part, every dimension is modeled from a real physical measurement, so all the information jives. The softwareused in the 3D world is very sophisticated; mistakes with conflicting view information do not occur.

If a customer’s end result wishes have not been made explicit, Laser Design metrologists can sometimes make educated guesses based on experience as to what areas are kept “as-built” and which are corrected to “design intent.” On simple shapes such as flat surfaces and straight edges, this is not difficult to infer (see Figure 2 below). If a cube designed with 6-inch sides has 6.01” sides, then correcting the length to 6” is simple. One can also generally assume that the sides should be parallel and perpendicular to one another.

img22

However, as complexity of the part increases, options for “design intent” also increase exponentially and Laser Design engineers are no longer able to decide what is needed. If a shape is complex, how can the Laser Design metrologist decide what to “true” and what not to? For example, molded parts may have parting lines; parts cast in sand may be out of spec because the sand eroded, or have uneven surfaces from machining done on the finished part. Mounting and mating issues may make some dimensions of the part critical to its fit in an assembly. We simply don’t know without detailed instructions.

“As-Built vs. Design Intent” – What does that mean exactly?

Do you want the scan data to reflect the part exactly as it is built?
Or do you want what the designer intended, meaning a perfect model, without manufacturing flaws and variances?

“What Will the Customer Do with the Model?”

The level of complexity of your model is based what it will eventually be used for. The first decision to make is whether you just need surfaces, or do you also need features and design history?

Low Level: Surface Model. This is the simplest type of model

 Uses: To replicate a part or manufacture it as is with no future changes. To use in FEA analyses.

This is a difficult position to adhere to because humans are notorious for changing their minds and for repurposing designs.

However, over 90% of Laser Design customers are able to use this type of model in IGES or STEP format for their applications. This level of complexity is called a surface model. The surfaces are defined to a high accuracy and are easily manufacturable. It can also be used to cut a mold.

Editability: Only simple changes, such as mirroring, scaling up or down, etc. are possible. A customer would do well to carefully consider this option. A fully editable model usually costs 2-3 times more, so if you will never change the current version, it makes sense to use this type of model.

High Level: Solid Models: Parasolid or Native Solid. These types of models are more complex and costlier.

 Uses: To make part variations, with features and design history.

This type of model typically costs 2-3 times more than an IGES or STEP surface model but is easily edited. Sometimes this model is called a “parametric” model. It is solid and the designer is able to define the part and create design rules with which to edit the part. The software defines the parameters and how to modify them, creating a history of the design process.

Editability: Design engineers are faced with complex design decisions everyday. This level of complexity can contain design information to make modifications consistently when changes are desired.

For example if the weight of a part needed to be reduced, several options could be tried: decreasing length of the part, making the walls thinner, making an opening larger, etc. Or if a part with a hole was to be increased in size the engineer could create a design rule that either moved the hole in relation to size of part, or keep hole in same spot regardless of size of part so that it would match an assembly. (See Figure 3.)

img23

Ideally, the customers can effectively communicate their needs so Laser Design engineers can efficiently explain what level of complexity is required in the scan files. Building understanding between customer and Laser Design engineer is an extremely important step in the modeling process. While it sounds straightforward to use the customer’s native software in building the editable model, the truth is that modeling is an art form that embraces many variables: two engineers will create the same model differently and both versions can be called parametric (editable) models. However, the models will behave differently when modifications are attempted. Hence, excellent communication between the customer and engineer doing the modeling is essential to guarantee the appropriateness and usefulness of the reverse engineered parametric model. Laser Design’s goal is always to provide the customer with the best model at the best price.

 

The Laser Design Process

The flow chart below illustrates the Laser Design quote process. As the flow proceeds downward, the amount of information about design intent (required accuracies and density) becomes greater and more complex. The scanning expertise needed from Laser Design engineers also increases. This results in the price increasing and the turnaround time increasing, as well as the editability and complexity of the deliverable scan files.

img24

Filed Under: Case Studies

About Laser Design

Laser Design, a CyberOptics Corporation Brand, has been a leading supplier of 3D scanning systems and services since 1987. Laser Design helps customers successfully solve their most complex 3D inspection, analysis, and reverse engineering challenges quickly, giving them a competitive advantage.

Whether the 3D solution needed is a new 3D scanner or a service project performed in our lab or at your site – Laser Design’s expert metrologists and experienced engineers have you covered – on your schedule, within your budget and with ultra accuracy & results our customers have come to expect.

  • Learning Portal
    • Sample Files
    • Blog
    • Case Studies
    • News
    • Videos
    • What is 3D Scanning?
    • 3D Technology Glossary
    • ROI of 3D Scanning
ldi-exp_246-254

What Customers are Saying…

Keurig
“Customer service is top notch! The part modeling was spot on requiring no additional CAD work. Delivery of the 3D model was fast and competitively priced.” –W.W. @ Keurig

Question about 3D Scanning?

Ask a 3D Expert>>

Sign-up for our eNews:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
  • Videos
  • eNews
Sign-up For Our Newsletter
PRODUCTS
  • 3D Scanners
    • Portable 3D Scanners
    • Desktop 3D Scanner
    • CT (X-ray) Scanners
    • Metrology Grade Scanners
    • Body Scanners
    • 3D Scanners for CMMs
  • Software & Accessories
    • 3D Anti-Glare Spray
    • Artec Studio
    • InnovMetric-Polyworks Software
    • Geomagic Software
    • Space Claim Software
    • Volume Graphics Software
    • ExactFlat Software
SERVICES
  • 3D Scanning
    • Parts & Objects
    • Buildings & Structures (BIM)
    • Aircraft, Vehicles & Large Objects
    • ITAR – Weapons
    • Industrial CT Scanning
    • Reverse Engineering
    • Inspection & Metrology
  • Point Cloud Modeling
  • 3D Photorealistic Rendering
  • View all services »

Solutions
Industries
Applications

About Us

Learning Portal

Contact Us
Laser Design
5900 Golden Hills Drive
Minneapolis, MN 55416

All Locations

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | 952-884-9648

© 2023 CyberOptics Corporation. All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie SettingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
SAVE & ACCEPT