Laser Design Inc and GKS Inspection Services Logo
The Leader in 3D Laser Scanning Systems & Services
enews eNews:

Dual-Purpose Reverse Engineering of Complex Porsche Engine Parts

Typically, laser scanning is ten times faster than the most advanced touch probe speed because lasers are able to collect over 75,000 3D coordinates per second.

The Challenge

An individual sportscar enthusiast was in the process of restoring a 1960s Porsche.  He wanted the engine to run at 7600 rpm, but the three original cast rocker arms could not handle the stresses generated at that speed.  He needed new parts whose functional shapes were identical to the old ones, but whose material physical properties were different (stronger).

The enthusiast had tried to measure the parts with calipers, but the shapes were too complex to make thorough accurate measurements.  He has also tried having a machinist reproduce and transfer the geometries of the three rocker-style arms to aluminum roller-style rocker arms instead of cast steel “tappet”-style rockers. After many attempts, none of the rockers was close to spec and the third, more complex rocker proved to be impossible to measure and recreate even after multiple tries with manual measuring techniques.

The customer sent the original and the prototype aluminum rockers along with the engine head to GKS Inspection Services to be laser scanned.

The Solution

At GKS, the three original rockers were scanned as well as the three aluminum prototypes on the Surveyor WS-2030 (20” X 30” X 20” work volume), a dual-purpose Wenzel CMM with Laser Design 3D laser scanning technology.  With the ultra-precise SLP-250 laser line scanning probe, the system obtained superior accuracies of 10µ per point with averaging.

The parts were mounted on the CMM’s programmable rotary stage to capture the geometry from several different orientations.   The WS-2030 native software, Surveyor Scan Control, takes only a few minutes to set up and runs automatically unattended. Even scanning six parts from several perspectives, the process was fast and the results were perfect.  

Typically, laser scanning is ten times faster than the most advanced touch probe speed because lasers are able to collect over 75,000 3D coordinates per second.  Laser scanning is ideal for improving part quality because the whole surface of an object is scanned, not just landmark dimensions, so free-form surfaces and irregular shapes are easily captured.  The rockers were scanned completely in a few minutes for each part, outputting millions of coordinates defining the complete shape.  Geomagic Studio software was used for processing the data and models were exported in SolidWorks.

The Results

From the sets of scans, GKS reverse engineering specialists were able to reengineer the more robust shape of the prototypes into the originals’ and correct out of spec areas.  “We actually placed a standardized roller on the valve side of the rocker where the original was only a solid radius,” explained the engineer.  “We analyzed and matched the complex geometry of the rockers and created a model.  The customer ran the model through virtual failure analysis software and, after a few changes, he had modern-style rocker arm models which could withstand the rpm’s of his newly rebuilt motor.”

The ultra-precise touch probe measuring capability (to ±3µ) combined with the high-speed laser scanning technology make this process fast, automated, user-friendly, and ultimately less expensive. The manual measuring method tried prior to laser scanning was labor intensive, time consuming, not as precise, and ultimately failed to yield usable measurements. The sportscar enthusiast customer spent much time and money to determine that because of the complexity of the part, contact manual measurement would not provide the results he required to rebuild the engine to the desired rpm capacity, whereas the Wenzel – Laser Design CMM did so easily.

Laser Design’s integration of the SLP laser scanning probe technology with the high mechanical accuracy of the Wenzel CMM brings the best of both worlds to one measuring system.  Existing Wenzel CMM users will be amazed at the time and cost savings and the superb accuracies of using non-contact 3D laser measurement with Wenzel’s laser scanning partner, Laser Design, Inc.

About Laser Design, Inc.

Laser Design, Inc. has been the leading supplier of ultra-precise, 3D laser scanning systems and services for over 20 years.  Used for capturing the 3D shape of objects with complex geometries and free-form surfaces, Laser Design’s Surveyor line of automated and portable scanning systems are ideal for 3D scanning applications involving inspection and reverse engineering of complex shaped plastic and metal parts.  The company’s patented laser line-probe technology dramatically reduces scanning time by collecting data substantially faster and more accurately than conventional metrology technologies. For more information contact us.